Ice cream cakes are, of course, a great choice for a birthday party, ... That, coupled with the hefty price tag, meant this cake fell to the middle of the rankings. 2nd Place: Carvel.

This ice cream cake was comprised of about 2/3 ice cream and 1/3 cake, and the entire dessert was coated with a thick layer of frosting. It felt more like a true cake than DQ’s option.